With the safety and security of Israel in mind, one must ask, what is the best solution to finally resolve the current situation in Gaza? Land for Peace, a concept which perhaps seemed like the best of options some 30 years ago (the Oslo Accords) and which was further acted upon some 18 years ago (the Disengagement from Gaza) quickly deteriorated when the population of Gaza voted a terrorist organization into power, who tore up the greenhouses of Gush Katif to build the rockets of their so-called resistance.
Since it left Gaza, Israel has only seen terrorism and radicalism on its western border. The idea of Gaza as a sanctuary for Palestinians was hijacked by Hamas, who turned Gaza into a hotbed for radical Islam and extremism, as it remains to this very day. The current conflict, which was brought on by the horrific actions of Hamas against Israeli civilians on October 7th, demands we reassess the situation concerning the best solution for all parties (minus any terrorist organizations). Since the creation of Gaza as an area exclusively for Palestinians in 2005-2006, there have always been major security concerns for the Israeli government and even more so, for Israelis living in the border towns of the Israel-Gaza border. Those concerns were horrifically realized on the day of October 7th, when approximately 3000 armed terrorists crossed the border between Gaza and Israel to indiscriminately kill, torture, rape, and mutilate men, women, and children. Now more than 90 days later, with an ongoing war in Gaza, the question that must be asked is; What should be done, to bring lasting peace for Israel, for the Gazan refugees, and for the sake of the entire region?
Currently, the refugee crisis in Gaza is being exacerbated by Palestinian and EU officials who, it would seem, believe that the only way to prevent Gaza from being fully controlled by Israel is by keeping Palestinian civilians in harm’s way. Haaretz headlines from 6 days ago stated: “Palestinian PM to Senior EU Officials: Aid Gaza to Prevent Mass Migration.” The idea presented here is the notion that we should keep Gazan civilians in Gaza; in the areas of combat to prevent mass migration. Very strange. Israel has always been accused of keeping Gazans confined in an open-air prison with no option of leaving, and yet suddenly, when Gazan civilians would need it most, and when Israelis suggest that this would be the wisest course of action to prevent unnecessary casualties, Palestinian and EU officials oppose the idea and instead want to keep civilians in the lines of fire.
What are these officials afraid of? That the people of Gaza might find better opportunities and livelihoods outside of the Gaza Strip? Why is this considered a bad thing? At the end of World War II, many Germans, who were not Nazis, were displaced from their homes until the Marshall plan was presented as an effective strategy to rebuild Europe. This lesson from history is how we should approach the current situation in Gaza. Palestinian civilians, who have been displaced by the current conflict, should be allowed to find a place of refuge until a proper plan for lasting peace can be decided upon.
It is an injustice to keep Gaza civilians inside of Gaza against their will. It is recorded that as of December of this past year, “More than 6.3 million refugees from Ukraine were recorded in Europe…” . Why is it suddenly a problem for the 2 million plus Palestinians of Gaza to find refuge away from the current conflict while Israel deals with rooting out the terrorist cancer in Gaza which is Hamas? Gazans should be allowed to pursue a life outside of the confines of Gaza and outside of the confines of the ongoing conflict. The PA and Hamas want to continue to use the civilian population as human shields by preventing them from leaving the Gaza Strip. This is inhumane. This is where we must expose the agenda of Hamas, the PA, and the EU, who want to continue the Gaza refugee crisis. Our goal should be to find lasting solutions for peace in the Middle East. The plan of the PA and EU to continue to keep innocent civilians in harm’s way and then blame Israel is unethical and inhumane.
All of that being said, it begs the question: what are the options that could and should be available for fleeing Gazans?
Here are some ideas being proposed at this time.
As was recorded in Arab News from 2017, “Saudi Arabia is one of the largest labor markets in the world with 11 million foreign workers from more than 100 countries represented in many sectors and fields of work…” Why not offer Gazans the option of becoming foreign workers in an Arabic speaking country like Saudi Arabia?
The Times of Israel recently reported, “Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition is conducting secret contacts for accepting thousands of immigrants from Gaza with Congo, in addition to other nations.” Why not allow Gazans the option to voluntarily immigrate to the Democratic Republic of the Congo and/or other African countries?
PBS News notes “People in the Gaza Strip who have Canadian relatives may apply for temporary visas to Canada, the country’s immigration minister said Thursday…” Here are some options for Gazans who have relatives in Canada. Why is this idea not being promoted more?
The EU, for all of their talk, has not opened up to allow Gazan refugees into any of their countries. As was noted by EuroNews; Joseph Borell Fontelles, who is the European Union’s Representative for Foreign Affairs, stated on Twitter/X, “Forced displacements are strictly prohibited as a grave violation of IHL (international humanitarian law) …” However, Israel is not looking to forcibly displace anyone. The current question is not regarding forced displacement, but rather, where to allow Palestinians to go while the current conflict rages on.
Why will the EU not open its doors to allow Gazan refugees to find shelter while Israel deals with the terrorist organization Hamas?
These are just a few of the many options that should be opened to allow the innocents of Gaza a haven away from the current conflict. Israel must destroy the current cancer which is Hamas—an oppressive, barbaric group, that terrorizes not only Israelis but also their fellow Gazans. This in turn will allow for new opportunities for co-existence and partnership between Israel and Palestinians who desire peace over another terror state. As we look at the current situation, there is no “best solution,” but these are better alternatives, compared to keeping innocent Palestinian civilians in harm’s way. The people of Gaza should not be pawns in the hands of Hamas or the PA, instead, we should tell the world to “Let the people of Gaza go!”
Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass.
◄ 1 Samuel 15:3 ►
When war started, I suggested that Gazans should b migrated to Iran.
Al those who are supporters of Hamas or Islamic Djihad realy should be taken in by Iran. Since it being the supporter or even instigator of the terror organisation Hamas he should also help them in their defeat and give them refuge.
Copy that.
After Al Husseinian left Israel, by 1941, and had met 3 or more times with Adolf Hilter to ask for advice as to how to set-up the Palestinian Territory in God’s Chosen Land, that Evil handshake between Husseinian and Hilter was set in the Devil’s Stone, to be thrown against God’s Loving Will.
That, if the Palestinian People would have enough courage to Stand-Up with some self-worth and Fight against Hamas and the other Iranian Proxies (all Terrorists), who CLEARLY OCCUPY Gaza and have for decades cut-off and stolen Israeli Aid assets to the Palestinians, only then could anyone with a rational mind allow for a Two-State Solution.
To boot, I just lost a lot of respect for Turkey’s Erdogan, after yesterday’s reports he is now siding with Iran.
None of US want to see anyone killed, not any human being, and especially not women and children. But War is hell, no matter what front it lay. And for Antony Blinken and JOETUS “Head of the Trojan Horse” Biden criticizing Israel for defending themselves against raw terror attacks on their own soil, our US Drones too, have after 9/11 missed a few targets and killed Civilians.
The Raw Fight Against Evil is Never Easy, and Old Memories of The Middle East Die Hard.
For now, I chose to keep Everyone in Our Lord’s Prayer, Everyone. And, if our Israeli Brethren were to call me to come and fight at their side today, it would be an Honor. For now, we must prepare for what is surely to come to US, soon; all of the Terror Sleeper Cells JOETUS Biden invited to cross our Southern Border since J6 2021.
Like Israel, Our Front is now where We Stand.
Another option would be that the civilians could be removed to temporary refugee camps in the Arab states, where they could be safe and could pursue permanent emigration if they chose. After Hamas has been destroyed, those civilians wishing to return could.
What will be important is that a peaceful government be established in Gaza, one that will pursue a path of peace, improving the economy rather than making war with Israel.
The other Middle East countries don’t want Palestinians- they have seen what happens. The countries of the EU are already over run with hate filled Muslims who are destroying their cultures- they don’t want any more of them. I understand that not all Palestinians are bad people, but the history of their culture is not encouraging to any country that might let them come, even for a little bit. They won’t want to go back when they discover the relative ease of living somewhere else.
Congo might need workers, but many places in Africa are no safer than Gaza and the Muslim influence across that continent is also wrecking havoc.
Many around the world have a “they made their bed, let them lie in it “ attitude because of the activities Palestinians have allowed to fester in their own country, their insistence, even now, that Hamas is a good thing and their want to destroy Israel. And, meanwhile, communities everywhere are being impacted by the ridiculous protests and riots insisting Israel simply give in- San Francisco even voted for a cease fire, as if their opinion matters- and “Palestine” go from the river to the sea.
Israel seems to have learned from history repeating itself and this time , I pray, they will destroy Hamas as much as is possible, with no remant left. Perhaps other countries have also reviewed the history books and decided these are not a people who want to live peacefully with others.
Maybe the Palestinians could decide to live in Peace with their neighbors. My first thought is Israel should be safe.
Terrific analysis. Thank you.
I am an American and only know what I read. However, I agree with Allison that many countries would be loath to allow immigration to a people so fond of extremism of the worst kind.
I think Gaza should be cleaned out along with the so called West Bank. Israel has put up with these people who want to destroy them for long enough. It is a big lie that it is Palestinian Land. Now not only has Israel got Palestinian enemies but the Palestinians are trying to turn the rest of world against Israel. Such nice people, l think not.
Israel will never know peace as long as Palestinians exist. Turn Gaza into a parking lot.
It is time for Israel to reclaim their Promised Land. Those leaders/politicians who gave it away lost their lives because they gave away something that was God-given for a purpose.
Gazans are refugees from surrounding Arab nations – 1948 history. I pray that Israel is successful in their negotiations with one/some of those nations to take them back. Saudi Arabia is a good option as some Gazans have ancestral roots there.
According to surveys from the Arab communities occupying Israeli land, 73% support Hamas. Israel should not have to live under such stress. Would any other nations tolerate such stress, hatred and invasion as happened on October 7? We all need to examine ourselves.
flatten it leave nothing but a flat scraped/cleansed land